Fantasy Hockey Goaltending Deep Dive: 2025 Season Review & Future Projections

Comprehensive analysis of NHL goalie performance in fantasy hockey with expert predictions for the 2025-26 season, including breakout candidates and strategy tips.

The Changing Landscape of Fantasy Goaltending

Over the past decade, we've witnessed a dramatic shift in fantasy hockey goaltending value. Where once netminders dominated the upper echelons of fantasy rankings, recent seasons have seen a significant decline in their overall impact - but signs point to a potential resurgence.

Historical Perspective:

  • 2014-15 Season: 7 of top 10 fantasy players were goalies
  • 2017-18 Season: 6 of top 10 were netminders
  • 2019-20 Season: Major decline with only 2 top-10 goalies
  • 2023-24 Season: Rock bottom with zero goalies in top 10

Current Season Trends

The 2024-25 campaign represents a slight rebound for fantasy goalies:

  • A goaltender has reclaimed the #1 overall fantasy spot
  • Two netminders projected to finish top-10 (matching 2019-20 numbers)
  • Nine goalies likely to land in top 100 fantasy players

Key Factors Influencing Performance:

  1. Timeshares: Increased crease splitting reduces individual value
  2. Age Fluctuations: Top-10 goalie age dropped to 27.6 (2022-23) before rebounding to 30.3
  3. Emerging Talent: New generation of young goalies developing

Team-by-Team Fantasy Outlook

Top Contenders:

  • Winnipeg Jets: Connor Hellebuyck (#1 fantasy goalie) continues to dominate
  • Tampa Bay Lightning: Andrei Vasilevskiy remains elite (#2 ranked)
  • Minnesota Wild: Filip Gustavsson emerging as top-3 option

Rising Stars:

  • Calgary Flames: Dustin Wolf (#10 among goalies) shows great promise
  • Carolina Hurricanes: Pyotr Kochetkov ready for breakout season
  • Montreal Canadiens: Sam Montembeault positioned for major improvement

Buy-Low Candidates:

  • New York Rangers: Igor Shesterkin likely to rebound after "down" year
  • New Jersey Devils: Jacob Markstrom with top-10 potential if healthy
  • Los Angeles Kings: Darcy Kuemper proving age is just a number

Future Projections for 2025-26

We're likely seeing the beginning of a goaltending renaissance:

  • Current sub-30 goalies will mature with more experience
  • Several top prospects (Yaroslav Askarov, Jesper Wallstedt) near NHL-ready
  • Improved defensive systems across league could boost goalie stats

Draft Strategy Recommendations:

  1. Early Rounds: Target proven workhorses (Hellebuyck, Vasilevskiy)
  2. Mid Rounds: Take shots on young talent (Wolf, Kochetkov)
  3. Late Rounds: Consider high-upside backups on good teams

Pro Tip: Monitor playoff performances as they may significantly alter 2025-26 draft stocks for many goalies.

What to Read Next

NHL Offseason Trade Analysis: Grading Key Moves from Coyle to Zegras
NHL

NHL Offseason Trade Analysis: Grading Key Moves from Coyle to Zegras

Explore in-depth analysis and grades of major NHL offseason trades, including key player movements and team strategies shaping the 2025 season.

Analyzing the Impact of the Charlie Coyle Trade: Avalanche and Blue Jackets' Strategic Moves
NHL

Analyzing the Impact of the Charlie Coyle Trade: Avalanche and Blue Jackets' Strategic Moves

Explore the strategic implications of the Charlie Coyle trade between the Colorado Avalanche and Columbus Blue Jackets, focusing on salary cap management and team dynamics.

NHL Trade Analysis: Montreal Canadiens and New York Islanders' Strategic Moves for Noah Dobson
NHL

NHL Trade Analysis: Montreal Canadiens and New York Islanders' Strategic Moves for Noah Dobson

An in-depth analysis of the strategic NHL trade involving Noah Dobson between the Montreal Canadiens and New York Islanders, focusing on future impacts and team dynamics.

NHL Free Agency 2025: Fantasy Hockey Impact of Key Signings and Trades
NHL

NHL Free Agency 2025: Fantasy Hockey Impact of Key Signings and Trades

Explore the fantasy hockey implications of NHL free agency moves and trades, including key player roles and potential risers for the 2025 season.

Utah Mammoth Secures Top Talent: J.J. Peterka Trade Analysis and Impact
NHL

Utah Mammoth Secures Top Talent: J.J. Peterka Trade Analysis and Impact

Explore the strategic NHL trade that brings J.J. Peterka to Utah Mammoth, analyzing its impact on both teams and future prospects.

Top NHL Draft Picks: A Legacy of Excellence from Ovechkin to Celebrini
NHL

Top NHL Draft Picks: A Legacy of Excellence from Ovechkin to Celebrini

Explore the history of NHL's No. 1 draft picks, from legendary players like Alexander Ovechkin to rising stars like Macklin Celebrini.

Top NHL Hall of Fame Candidates for 2026: Who Will Make the Cut?
NHL

Top NHL Hall of Fame Candidates for 2026: Who Will Make the Cut?

Explore the top NHL players and women's hockey stars likely to be inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2026, including Patrice Bergeron, Carey Price, and more.

Connor McDavid's NHL Future: Will He Stay with the Oilers or Test Free Agency in 2026?
NHL

Connor McDavid's NHL Future: Will He Stay with the Oilers or Test Free Agency in 2026?

Connor McDavid's future with the Edmonton Oilers is uncertain as he approaches the final year of his contract. Will he re-sign or explore free agency in 2026?

Analyzing the Impact of the Trevor Zegras Trade: Flyers and Ducks' Strategic Moves
NHL

Analyzing the Impact of the Trevor Zegras Trade: Flyers and Ducks' Strategic Moves

A detailed analysis of the Trevor Zegras trade between the Philadelphia Flyers and Anaheim Ducks, exploring the strategic implications for both teams.

Brad Marchand's Epic Stanley Cup Victory Tour: From Crowd-Surfing to Dairy Queen
NHL

Brad Marchand's Epic Stanley Cup Victory Tour: From Crowd-Surfing to Dairy Queen

Explore Brad Marchand's unforgettable Stanley Cup victory tour with the Florida Panthers, from crowd-surfing to working at Dairy Queen.

2025 Stanley Cup Playoff Beards: Celebrating the Best Facial Hair in NHL History
NHL

2025 Stanley Cup Playoff Beards: Celebrating the Best Facial Hair in NHL History

Discover the most iconic playoff beards of the 2025 Stanley Cup Final, featuring standout players from the Florida Panthers and Edmonton Oilers.

Florida Panthers: The Dual Nature of Back-to-Back Stanley Cup Champions
NHL

Florida Panthers: The Dual Nature of Back-to-Back Stanley Cup Champions

Explore how the Florida Panthers balanced their on-ice aggression with off-ice camaraderie to secure back-to-back Stanley Cup victories.

Florida Panthers Claim Back-to-Back Stanley Cup Titles with Dominant Victory Over Edmonton Oilers
NHL

Florida Panthers Claim Back-to-Back Stanley Cup Titles with Dominant Victory Over Edmonton Oilers

The Florida Panthers secured their second consecutive Stanley Cup by defeating the Edmonton Oilers 5-1, showcasing their offensive prowess and defensive strength.

Calvin Pickard: The Unsung Hero Behind Oilers' Stanley Cup Final Rally
NHL

Calvin Pickard: The Unsung Hero Behind Oilers' Stanley Cup Final Rally

Calvin Pickard steps up as the Edmonton Oilers' backbone in the Stanley Cup Final, showcasing resilience and skill under pressure.

Stanley Cup Showdown: Panthers vs. Oilers Game 5 - Who Will Take the Lead?
NHL

Stanley Cup Showdown: Panthers vs. Oilers Game 5 - Who Will Take the Lead?

As the Stanley Cup Final heats up, the Florida Panthers and Edmonton Oilers face off in a pivotal Game 5. Who will edge closer to the ultimate prize?

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.