Manchester United's struggles continue as Brighton defeat piles pressure on Ruben Amorim

Manchester United suffered a 3-1 home defeat to Brighton, prompting Ruben Amorim to take the criticism for a team whose problems run much deeper.Elsewhere, Antonio Conte's Napoli took another step towards a Serie A title, while Tottenham's crisis deepened around Ange Postecoglou.

Manchester United's struggles continue as Brighton defeat piles pressure on Ruben Amorim

Manchester United suffered a 3-1 home defeat to Brighton, prompting Ruben Amorim to take the criticism for a team whose problems run much deeper.Elsewhere, Antonio Conte's Napoli took another step towards a Serie A title, while Tottenham's crisis deepened around Ange Postecoglou.

Ruben Amorim holds himself accountable... but did anyone ask him to?

Sunday's 3-1 home defeat to Brighton was pretty brutal for Manchester United. Take away Bruno Fernandes' penalty and the xG was 0.69 (to Brighton's 1.93) with zero shots on target.

But guess what? So was their previous outing, Thursday night's 3-1 win over Southampton, a game they were losing until Amad Diallo's hat-trick beginning in the 37th minute of the second half. If you grade on a curve -- based on the fact that Brighton are battling for Europe, while Southampton are on pace to have the fewest points of any team in Premier League history -- that one was just as bad.

I get that, but I'm not sure it was necessary for Amorim to go all doom-and-gloom after the Brighton match, saying his was "maybe the worst team in the history of the club," that they "need to survive" and that he's "not helping [his] players in the moment."

It's not because they are nowhere near the worst team in United history -- that would be the 1933-34 team, who avoided relegation to the third flight on the last day of the season. Rather, it's because nobody is calling for his head right now, nobody is accusing him of scapegoating others, and nobody think he's deluded. United fans -- and neutrals who frankly miss them as a serious club -- simply want him to keep working and see if he can turn the club around.

Lack of accountability is a thing, sure, but not with Amorim. However, too much accountability isn't a great thing.

Most observers understand that Amorim had three things to do when he took over: assess the players and figure out who may need to be replaced, teach them his brand of football (and they obviously have a ways to go in that department), and move the club up the table so they can get the revenue they'll need to strengthen in the summer (he's not getting it done in this department).

But nobody is calling for his head. Nobody is blaming him -- not yet, anyway, and given how long the club put up with Erik Ten Hag and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer (and given how expensive it is to fire someone) that won't happen for a while. All he has to do is say, "Yes, we all need to do a better job, but we'll get there."

What seems evident is that, individual errors aside, United have started to metabolize some of his defensive mechanisms, though their use of the ball and patterns of play in possession leave a lot to be desired. That's why, incidentally, they've looked better against better sides like Liverpool or Arsenal, especially on the road, than they have at home, where they've had to try to take the initiative. We can debate whether he has the players to do that, but that's what he needs to deliver if United are to progress. And that will take time.

There may also come a point -- maybe very soon, if they lose at Fulham on Sunday -- when they'll be tempted to "tank" the league and focus on the Europa League and FA Cup. The fact of the matter is there are 12 points (and eight clubs) between them and the Champions League places -- 11 points (and six clubs) to the Europa League spots. That is a lot of ground to make up with 16 games to go.

Might they be better off concentrating their energy on the cup competitions and using the Premier League as a chance to learn and grow in Amorim's system? It's going to be a big call to make, and Amorim hopes it won't come to that.

Antonio Conte is on his way to doing it again after Napoli's huge win at Atalanta

We may end up remembering this as a season-defining victory, not just because Atalanta were third in the table, but also because the last time they played they whupped Napoli 3-0 away. On Saturday night, Napoli took what Atalanta (who played very well going forward) threw at them, weathered the storm, punished opposition mistakes and won 3-2 thanks to a late Romelu Lukaku header at the end of a riveting 90-plus minutes.

Atalanta boss Gian Piero Gasperini said losing like this "hurts," and presumably he was referring to the fact that you can pinpoint a defensive error on each of Napoli's three goals. He's right, but there's a lot to be said for Napoli's ability to both neuter their attack -- they were outshot 15 to 6 and still won the xG battle -- and be ruthless in exploiting their chances.

Games like this feed the Conte narrative about hard work and intensity, and they further cement his grip on this Napoli team. We scoff at this at our peril, but there is no question that he's one of the best in the world at getting immediate buy-in from his players. He said so himself after the game, when asked about whether he expected the club to sign a replacement for PSG-bound Khvicha Kvaratskhelia: "If they ask my opinion I'll give it. But if somebody comes, it needs to be someone who can contribute right away, not just some promising youngster. Otherwise, I'll stick to the guys I have, because I trust them and I know they'll go to war with me and won't let me down."

The fact is Napoli have no cup football and only need to play another 17 games between now and the end of the season. He doesn't need more bodies: the ones he has will run through a brick wall for him.

Lest we forget, of the Napoli XI that won the title two years ago, four key pieces -- Victor Osimhen, Kvaratskhelia, Piotr Zielinski and Min-Jae Kim -- are now gone. Their replacements are Lukaku, David Neres, Scott McTominay and Alessandro Buongiorno. Except for the latter, the other three, on paper, are evident downgrades and yet, once again, he has shown the ability to make players better... at least in the short-term.

Injuries ravage Tottenham, and Ange Postecoglou's 'fixes' make things worse

And yet, you can only blame him to a point. When you have 11 unavailable first-team players, you can either plug in some youth teamers or you can devise a new scheme to accommodate the ones you do have. Postecoglou chose the latter, shifting to a back three and playing Dejan Kulusevski and James Maddison as wide men. It's a setup we hadn't seen before from Spurs and, by Postecoglou's own admission, it "probably made things worse" as they went into halftime 3-0 down at Everton.

We can second-guess all we like and try to reconfigure the Spurs puzzle with the ill-fitting pieces available, but there was no obvious "better solution" -- just a lot of Monday Morning Quarterbacking. And possibly because Everton had not actually won a game since Dec. 4 and had just sacked their manager, Postecoglou thought he could get away with it.

The fightback in the second half to 3-2 suggests that Spurs aren't lacking spirit; they're mostly lacking players. That's the good news. The question is when the injured players return, what the table will look like when they do and at what point folks lose faith in Postecoglou. Because the fact of the matter is that this already stretched squad has Europa League, FA Cup and League Cup commitments too. And while eight points from the relegation zone feels like a lot, it can go away pretty quickly once you start to slide.

What to Read Next

James Tarkowski Commits Future to Everton with New Deal – European Ambitions Take Center Stage
Football

James Tarkowski Commits Future to Everton with New Deal – European Ambitions Take Center Stage

Everton's defensive stalwart James Tarkowski signs contract extension through 2028 while outlining ambitious European qualification plans under David Moyes' leadership.

Sir Jim Ratcliffe Backs Ruben Amorim: Exclusive Insight into Manchester United’s 3-Year Roadmap to Glory
Football

Sir Jim Ratcliffe Backs Ruben Amorim: Exclusive Insight into Manchester United’s 3-Year Roadmap to Glory

Manchester United co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe outlines long-term vision for success under Ruben Amorim, defending the manager’s project while addressing financial restructuring and fan expectations in this exclusive analysis.

David Raya Signs Enhanced Arsenal Deal: Golden Glove Hero Cements Key Role Under Arteta
Football

David Raya Signs Enhanced Arsenal Deal: Golden Glove Hero Cements Key Role Under Arteta

Arsenal solidify their defensive foundations as David Raya signs improved terms following back-to-back Golden Glove campaigns, with analysis of his record-breaking shot-stopping impact in North London.

Premier League's 007 Club: When Star Signings Struggle to Deliver Goals & Assists
Football

Premier League's 007 Club: When Star Signings Struggle to Deliver Goals & Assists

Exploring football's '007' phenomenon where high-profile signings go seven matches without goals or assists, featuring Florian Wirtz, Jadon Sancho, and Thierry Henry's redemption arc.

Mohamed Salah's Defensive Dilemma: How Liverpool's Tactical Imbalance Threatens Their Title Ambitions
Football

Mohamed Salah's Defensive Dilemma: How Liverpool's Tactical Imbalance Threatens Their Title Ambitions

Examining how Mohamed Salah's limited defensive contributions expose Liverpool's tactical flaws against elite opponents, with insights into Arne Slot's system and potential solutions.

Tottenham Takeover Drama: Brooklyn Earick Withdraws Bid as Club Reaffirms Commitment to Levy's Legacy
Football

Tottenham Takeover Drama: Brooklyn Earick Withdraws Bid as Club Reaffirms Commitment to Levy's Legacy

Tech mogul Brooklyn Earick abandons Spurs acquisition plans after rejected approach, as Tottenham's board doubles down on retaining control amid post-Levy era transitions.

Late-Game Drama Turns Sour: Liverpool's Defensive Collapse & Title Defense Crisis
Football

Late-Game Drama Turns Sour: Liverpool's Defensive Collapse & Title Defense Crisis

An in-depth analysis of Liverpool's dramatic shift from late-game heroes to victims, exposing tactical flaws and mounting pressure in their Premier League title defense campaign.

Senne Lammens' Manchester United Debut: A Goalkeeping Gamble or Hidden Gem?
Football

Senne Lammens' Manchester United Debut: A Goalkeeping Gamble or Hidden Gem?

Senne Lammens' maiden Manchester United appearance sparks debate as fans draw Schmeichel comparisons. Analysis of his performance, tactical decisions, and what lies ahead for the Belgian shot-stopper.

Wayne Rooney's Definitive Ranking: The Greatest Defenders of the Modern Era and Why Today's Stars Fall Short
Football

Wayne Rooney's Definitive Ranking: The Greatest Defenders of the Modern Era and Why Today's Stars Fall Short

Wayne Rooney analyzes the evolution of defensive play, ranking his top 5 Champions League defenders while critiquing modern Premier League center-backs. Discover why he claims today's stars can't match legends like Terry and Maldini.

Ange Postecoglou's Nottingham Forest Crisis: Mounting Pressure Ahead of Newcastle Clash
Football

Ange Postecoglou's Nottingham Forest Crisis: Mounting Pressure Ahead of Newcastle Clash

Nottingham Forest manager Ange Postecoglou faces growing scrutiny after a winless start, with Sunday's Premier League clash against Newcastle United looming as a pivotal moment for his tenure.

Savinho Commits Long-Term: Man City’s Rising Star Signs Until 2031
Football

Savinho Commits Long-Term: Man City’s Rising Star Signs Until 2031

Manchester City secures Brazilian winger Savinho’s future with a contract extension until 2031, as Pep Guardiola hails the 21-year-old’s potential to become a 'top-class player'.

Transfer Talk: Real Madrid Shifts Focus from Konate as Premier League Clubs Ramp Up January Plans
Football

Transfer Talk: Real Madrid Shifts Focus from Konate as Premier League Clubs Ramp Up January Plans

Latest transfer updates reveal Real Madrid cooling interest in Liverpool's Konate, Manchester United eyeing Brentford's Yarmolyuk, and Newcastle targeting Athletic Club's Sancet. Key insights into Premier League and European club strategies.

Manchester Rivals Unite: Football Clubs Honor Synagogue Attack Victims with Silent Tributes
Football

Manchester Rivals Unite: Football Clubs Honor Synagogue Attack Victims with Silent Tributes

Manchester United and Manchester City lead football's response to the Manchester synagogue attack through coordinated tributes, including black armbands and moments of silence across multiple fixtures.

Forest's New Era: Gibbs-White Vows Unstoppable Surge as Postecoglou Seeks European Spark
Football

Forest's New Era: Gibbs-White Vows Unstoppable Surge as Postecoglou Seeks European Spark

Nottingham Forest's transitional phase under Ange Postecoglou analyzed through tactical shifts, European ambitions, and squad mentality ahead of crucial Midtjylland clash.

Transfer Talk: Tottenham's Defensive Reinforcements and Manchester United's Midfield Ambitions Unveiled
Football

Transfer Talk: Tottenham's Defensive Reinforcements and Manchester United's Midfield Ambitions Unveiled

Explore the latest transfer rumors as Tottenham eye Crystal Palace's Marc Guehi and Brentford's Nathan Collins to bolster their defense. Meanwhile, Manchester United target Real Madrid's Federico Valverde and face managerial uncertainty under Ruben Amorim. Stay updated on Premier League moves and European club strategies.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.