The 2025 MLB All-Star Game is shaping up to be one of the most exciting in recent history, and much of the anticipation revolves around the decision of American League manager Aaron Boone. Boone, the Yankees' skipper, has the unenviable task of choosing the starting pitcher from a pool of elite aces: Tarik Skubal, Max Fried, Jacob deGrom, and Garrett Crochet. Each of these pitchers has a compelling case to take the mound at Truist Park in Atlanta.

Max Fried: The Yankees' Ace

Max Fried has been a revelation for the New York Yankees since signing as a free agent. With a 2.27 ERA in 19 starts, Fried has lived up to the hype. Scheduled to pitch on Saturday, he would be well-rested for the All-Star Game. Additionally, Fried’s history with the Atlanta Braves could make him a fan favorite in Atlanta.

Tarik Skubal: The Dominant Force

Tarik Skubal of the Detroit Tigers has been nothing short of dominant. Leading all pitchers in fWAR (4.7), Skubal has been unbeatable in his last 16 starts, boasting a 1.62 ERA with 138 strikeouts in 105⅓ innings. His recent performance against the Minnesota Twins, where he struck out 13 of 23 batters, underscores his elite status.

Jacob deGrom: The Veteran Comeback

Jacob deGrom, the Texas Rangers' ace, is back in top form. With a 2.29 ERA and a 0.912 WHIP, deGrom has been a key factor in the Rangers' success. Scheduled to start on Saturday, Boone will need to consult with Rangers manager Bruce Bochy to determine deGrom’s availability.

Garrett Crochet: The Red Sox' Reliable Arm

Garrett Crochet has been a constant for the Boston Red Sox in an otherwise unconventional season. Leading the majors in innings pitched (120⅓) and strikeouts (151), Crochet has posted a 2.39 ERA. His start on Saturday against the Rays will be his final audition for the All-Star nod.

Boone’s decision is far from easy, with each pitcher bringing unique strengths to the table. The announcement on Monday morning will be one of the most anticipated moments leading up to the All-Star Game.