The Controversial Decision

In a recent Premier League match between Arsenal and Wolves, a contentious red card decision has sparked widespread debate. Referees' chief Howard Webb admitted that Michael Oliver's decision to send off Arsenal's young talent, Myles Lewis-Skelly, was incorrect. The incident occurred during Arsenal's 1-0 victory at Molineux on January 25th.

The Incident

Lewis-Skelly, aged just 18, was shown a straight red card for a foul on Matt Doherty in the 43rd minute. VAR upheld the decision, leading to a three-match ban for the teenager, which was later overturned upon appeal. The decision has been heavily criticized, with former England captain Alan Shearer describing it as 'one of the worst decisions I've seen in a long time'.

Analysis of the Decision

On the BBC's Match of the Day and the Premier League Productions programme 'Match Officials Mic'd Up', Webb analyzed the incident. He stated that while the officials got it wrong, it wasn't a 'horrendous' decision. Webb explained that a yellow card would have been more appropriate in this situation, as the contact was more glancing than forceful.

Reactions from the Football Community

The decision split opinions among football pundits. Former Premier League referee Mike Dean supported the red card, citing the studs' placement on Doherty's leg. In contrast, former Chelsea and Scotland winger Pat Nevin was 'stunned' by the decision, arguing that it didn't resemble violent conduct.

Aftermath and Consequences

Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta expressed his frustration but chose to let the decision speak for itself. Meanwhile, Webb emphasized that VAR should have intervened, noting the 'glanced studs' from Lewis-Skelly that should have kept him on the pitch.

Social Media Abuse

The aftermath also saw referee Michael Oliver and his family receiving threats and abuse on social media, which PGMOL described as 'wholly unacceptable'. Oliver continued his duties, refereeing subsequent matches, including the Merseyside derby.

Conclusion

This incident highlights the complexities and pressures of refereeing in high-stakes Premier League matches. It also underscores the need for clearer guidelines and better utilization of VAR to ensure fair play and reduce controversy.